Dora finds a diamond ring on a public sidewalk in front of Frank's Jewelry Store. The ring belongs to Emma but is not marked in any way to allow Dora to return it. Who has the best claim to ownership of the ring?

a. The province because it was found on public property

b. Dora because Emma did not label the ring to prove ownership

c. Emma because she is the original owner

d. Frank because it was found outside his jewelry store

e. Dora because she has possession of the ring

Answer:

c. Emma because she is the original owner

Step-by-step explanation

In this case, I believe that the best person to claim to ownership of the ring is Emma. The distinction between the right to possession and the right to ownership will be key in this case. Like in this case where Emma lost the ring , the one who finds it has the right to possession but then, if Emma return to recover the ring, she has only lost the possession at some point but then she has a the right to possession and the right to ownership because she has not lost the original ownership which means that the move to recover the ring would warrant her, as the owner, the right to possession and ownership.