Subject:FinancePrice:2.86 Bought15
Shark Ltd. specialises in manufacturing low-price, high-volume accessories for mobile phones. Examples of the company’s products include phone cases and stylus pens for touch screens. Recently, the research and development (R & D) staff at Shark developed a faux leather case, which is specially designed to fit a new model of mobile phone which has just been launched by a major phone manufacturer. Based on past experience, Shark estimates that demand for this phone will be very strong for the next two years but will then largely cease as new phone models appear on the market. Shark’s financial manager has determined that, in order to manufacture and distribute the phone case, the company will need to make an immediate investment of €1,000,000 in new production and distribution facilities. The company finances this type of investment by raising capital funds from a combination of banks and shareholders, and a return of 4% per annum is required in order to justify this type of capital investment. Shark’s marketing manager is aware that Shark is not the only company developing a case for this particular phone. He believes that Shark should quickly build up market share by entering the market as soon as possible and selling its phone case at a highly competitive selling price. Specifically, he recommends that Shark should immediately start manufacturing the product and selling it for €3 per unit, while paying its sales staff a commission of €0.25 per unit sold. He believes that if this marketing strategy is adopted then Shark can realistically expect to sell 125,000 units per annum of the phone case over the next two years. The production manager has taken note of the financial manager’s and marketing manager’s recommendations and hopes that they will be adopted. His estimate of the cost of manufacturing the product is €2.53 per unit. Required: (a) Prepare calculations to indicate the target cost (per unit) of manufacturing the phone case. Then, explain clearly the significance of this figure. (10 marks) (b) Assume now that the general manager of Shark has said that “we should start manufacturing and selling this product so long as the expected sales revenue exceeds the combined manufacturing cost and sales commission”. Determine what percentage return on the €1,000,000 capital investment will be achieved if this recommendation is followed, and explain to the general manager (with detailed reasons) whether you recommend that this approach should be followed. (5 marks) (c) Assume now that, having reviewed the results of your analysis in answer to parts (a) and (b) above, the general manager of Shark Ltd. decided to refer the design back to the company’s R & D staff for further design work. She believes that this will result in a 6-month delay before Shark can bring its product to market, but will result in a significant reduction in the manufacturing cost without adversely affecting the quality of the product. Critically evaluate whether, with this approach, Shark can make a commercial success of the product.
a) The target cost per unit is calculated below
Cost of Manufacturing the product = €2.53
Add:- Sales commission per unit sold = €0.25
Total Cost = €2.78
The total cost per unit of manufacturing the product is €2.78
Therefore the total cost for manufacturing (including sales commission) 125,000 units will be
125,000 * €2.78 = €347,500
The minimum number of units to be sold to cover the above costs will be
Total Cost of manufacturing Sale price per unit
i.e. €347,500 €3 = 115,833 (approx)
So Shark has to sell atleast 115,833 to earn atleast a revenue which will cover combined manufacturing and sales commission.
The above cost per unit calculated is significant to the company to stay alive in the market without making any profit or loss and to cover the costs incurred.
b) Over the coming two years if the company expects to sell 125,000 units then the estimated profit is calculated below
Particulars | 1st Year | 2nd Year |
Sales (125,000 * €3) | €375,000 | €375,000 |
Less:- Manufacturing Cost (125,000 * 2.78) | €347,500 | €347,500 |
Estimated Profit | €27,500 | €27,500 |
Return on Investment = (Estimated Profit Invested Capital) * 100 = (€27,500
€1,000,000)*100 = 2.75%
The actual return on investment is 2.75% is less than the expected return of 4% to justify this kind of investment hence I will not recommend this investment as it is not generating the expected return
c) If the company anticipates a 4% return on investment then the desired net profit should be
. Investment amount * Desired return percentage = €1,000,000 * 4% = €40,000
To generate a net profit of €40,000 Shark has to reduce its cost to
New cost = Total sales - desired profit = €375,000 - €40,000 = €335,000
So, the total cost per unit of the product manufactured will be
Cost per unit = Total Cost No. of units sold = €2.68
The total manufacturing cost should be reduced to €2.68 (Cost per unit)- €0.25 (Sales Commission) = 2.43
If shark company can manage to reduce the cost of manufacturing to atleast €2.43 then the company can earn the desired return reducing the cost of manufacturing and also increasing the quality of the product.
With the approach above, If shark can penetrate into the market then the product will be commercial success.